|


| December 2001 |
Vol.4, No. 10
|
Making Sense of the Cloning
Claims
Fantastic claims about humans being
cloned for the first time splashed across newspaper headlines and were broadcast
from the electronic media on the weekend of Nov. 25-26. Are they true? Have human
beings been cloned by a biotech lab in Massachusetts? What is the significance of
this unbelievable claim?
by Cecil E. Maranville
With superb coordination more indicative of a marketing ploy or a political strategy
than a scientific announcement, Advanced Cell Technology, Inc. (ACT) declared to
the world in late November that its Massachusetts facility had successfully cloned
a human being on Oct. 31, 2001. Most news media dutifully reported the announcement
as fact. But is the company's claim true?
You would assume so, on the basis of most press reports. "First Human Embryo
Is Cloned," reported David Derbyshire, science correspondent for the U.K.'s
Electronic Telegraph. "U.S. Scientists Cloned Human Embryos," penned
Rick Weiss of the Nov. 25 Washington Post. NewScientist.com headlined the
story, "First Cloned Human Embryos Created." "The First Human Cloned
Embryo" is the title of an article published in the January issue of Scientific
American, written, by the way, by the principal corporate officers of ACT.
Joannie Fischer of U.S. News & World Report wrote the cover story for
its Dec. 3 issue: "Scientists have finally cloned a human embryo," says
the subtitle. "The breakthrough promises cures for terrible diseases."
Ms. Fischer has been reporting on the issue for the past 18 months and is no stranger
to the details of the cloning process or to ACT's research findings. She appeared
in a split-screen interview with Dr. Michael West, CEO of ACT, on NBC's Meet the
Press program Sunday Nov. 25, speaking glowingly of Dr. West's and ACT's "breakthrough."
Related Information on UCG Sites:
Table of Contents that includes "Making Sense of the Cloning Claims"
Other Articles by Cecil Maranville
Cloning:
Science and ethics:
Search Our Site
Key Subjects Index
General Topics Index
Biblical References Index
Good News Magazine Index
Booklets and All Literature Index
Home Page of this site
|